How to Know If Your Therapy Is Working: 9 Signs of Effective Treatment

Q: How do I know if I need a different therapist or if I'm avoiding difficult work?

Ask yourself if you feel respected, heard, and safe with your therapist. Productive discomfort is normal when addressing complex issues, but if you feel unsafe, disrespected, or see no progress after months, it may be time to change therapists.

Q: What should I do if my therapist breaks confidentiality inappropriately?

This is a serious ethical violation. Document what happened, then file a complaint with your state licensing board, contact their supervisor, and consider reporting to professional organizations. Find a new therapist immediately.

Q: How much should therapy cost, and does expensive mean better?

Therapy in the U.S. typically costs $100–250 per session without insurance, or $10–75 with insurance. Price doesn’t always equal quality. Focus on credentials, approach, and fit rather than cost alone.

Q: Can online therapy be as effective as in-person therapy?

Yes, research shows that online therapy can be just as effective for many concerns, including depression, anxiety, and PTSD. The key is finding a therapist you connect with who uses evidence-based approaches.

Q: What if I can't afford therapy?

Options include using insurance, finding sliding scale therapists, community mental health centers, university clinics, affordable online counseling, or contacting the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline for support and referrals.

Q: When should I consider ending therapy?

Consider ending therapy when you’ve achieved your goals, learned coping strategies, and feel equipped to handle challenges. Ending should be a collaborative decision with your therapist, and many people return later if needed.

Written by Dr. Julian Navarro, PhD, LCSW, Last Updated: October 13, 2025

Featured Programs:

1. Creates a Non-Judgmental Environment

Good therapy begins with safety. Your therapist should create an environment where you can share your deepest thoughts and feelings without fear of judgment, condemnation, or criticism. This concept, called "unconditional positive regard" by psychologist Carl Rogers, means your therapist maintains a positive view of you as a person, even when discussing challenging behaviors or thoughts.

In practice, this means:

No visible shock or disapproval when you share difficult experiences
Acceptance of your feelings without trying to talk you out of them
Validation of your experiences, even when offering different perspectives
A sense of safety that allows you to be vulnerable

You should feel comfortable discussing topics you might not share with anyone else. If you find yourself censoring your thoughts or worrying about your therapist's reaction, this may indicate a problem with the therapeutic relationship.

2. Keeps the Focus on You

Your therapy session should always be about you, your needs, and your growth. A good therapist keeps their personal issues separate from your treatment. Every meeting should feel productive and helpful to your specific situation.

Warning signs that the focus has shifted:

Your therapist shares personal problems during your session time
Stories about their life don't clearly relate to your therapeutic goals
They ask you for advice about their personal situations
Sessions feel more like friendship than professional treatment

While therapists may occasionally share relevant personal experiences to normalize your feelings or provide perspective, these disclosures should always serve your therapeutic needs, not theirs.

3. Explains Their Therapeutic Approach

Since Sigmund Freud began experimenting with therapy over a century ago, dozens of therapeutic approaches have emerged. No single method works for everyone, and different issues respond better to specific interventions. A good therapist should clearly explain which approach they're using and why it's appropriate for your particular concerns.

Common evidence-based therapeutic approaches include:

Approach	Best For	How It Works	Typical Duration
Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT)	Depression, anxiety, PTSD, OCD	Changes negative thought patterns that influence emotions and behaviors	12-20 sessions
Dialectical Behavior Therapy (DBT)	Borderline personality disorder, self-harm, and emotional regulation	Teaches mindfulness, distress tolerance, and interpersonal skills	6-12+ months*
Exposure Therapy	Phobias, panic disorder, PTSD	Gradual, safe exposure to feared situations reduces anxiety	8-15 sessions
Motivational Interviewing	Substance abuse, behavioral change	Explores ambivalence and builds motivation for change	1-8 sessions*
Psychodynamic Therapy	Relationship patterns, deep-seated issues	Explores unconscious patterns and past experiences	12-24 sessions to several years*

*Duration varies based on individual needs, treatment goals, and response to therapy. These are general guidelines, not rigid timeframes.

Your therapist should be able to explain their chosen method in plain language and justify why it's appropriate for your specific situation. If they can't clearly articulate their approach or why they selected it, consider seeking a second opinion.

4. Reviews Your Progress Regularly

Therapy without clear goals is like taking a trip without a destination. At the start of treatment, your therapist should work with you to establish specific, measurable therapeutic goals. These should be your goals, not what the therapist thinks you should want.

What good progress reviews look like:

Initial goal-setting within the first 1-3 sessions
Regular check-ins (typically every 4-6 sessions) on your progress
Honest conversations about what's working and what isn't
Flexibility to adjust approaches if progress stalls
Celebration of improvements, no matter how small

Your therapist should feel comfortable having clear, honest conversations about your progress. If you're not improving, they should be willing to try different approaches or refer you to another therapist whose methods might be more effective. A good therapist won't be offended by discussions about progress—they want you to succeed.

5. Maintains Confidentiality Appropriately

Confidentiality is fundamental to therapy. You need to trust that your secrets, fears, and experiences will remain private. However, confidentiality isn't absolute, and your therapist should clearly explain the exceptions during your first session.

When therapists must break confidentiality:

You're in danger of harming yourself (imminent suicide risk)
You're planning to harm someone else (duty to warn)
Child or elder abuse is occurring (mandated reporting)
Court orders require disclosure (varies by state)

These exceptions should be explained clearly before you begin therapy, ideally in writing. Many therapists review a confidentiality agreement during the first session. If your therapist can't clearly define what is and isn't confidential, or if they've breached confidentiality without legal justification, this is a serious red flag.

A note about technology: If your therapist communicates via email, text, or online platforms, they should explain that these methods aren't always secure and may not have the same confidentiality protections as in-person sessions.

6. Respects Your Cultural Beliefs

Culturally competent therapy means your therapist understands and respects your cultural background, religious beliefs, sexual orientation, gender identity, and other aspects of your identity. They should never make offensive comments or dismiss the importance of your cultural values.

What cultural competence looks like:

Asking about your cultural background and beliefs
Learning from you about cultural practices they don't understand
Adapting treatment to work within your cultural framework
Suggesting interventions that align with your values
Being willing to learn rather than making assumptions

You shouldn't have to educate your therapist about fundamental aspects of your identity, but it's reasonable for them to ask questions to better understand your unique cultural context. A good therapist will make suggestions that work with your beliefs and value system, not against them.

7. Listens to You Actively

Active listening is the foundation of therapy. Your therapist's primary job is to listen deeply to what you're saying, understand your perspective, and help you process difficult emotions and experiences.

Signs of active listening:

Remembers key facts about your life (names, essential events, ongoing situations)
Asks clarifying questions that show they're tracking with you
Reflects what you've said to ensure understanding
Picks up on emotional subtext beneath your words
Connects current issues to past discussions appropriately

While your therapist won't remember every minor detail, they should recall key information like your name, why you came to therapy, major ongoing stressors, and important people in your life. If you find yourself constantly reminding them of basic facts, they're not listening effectively.

8. Pays Attention During Sessions

Your therapy session should be a focused time dedicated entirely to you. Your therapist should give you their complete, undivided attention throughout the session.

Red flags for attention problems:

Checking their phone during your session (unless for clinical notes)
Frequently glancing at the clock in an obvious way
Interrupting sessions for non-emergency calls
Seeming distracted or not tracking with what you're saying
Focusing more on their computer than on you

Many therapists use computers or tablets to take notes during sessions, which is acceptable and can even be helpful. However, this note-taking should feel unobtrusive, and you should still feel like they're truly present and listening to you.

If your therapist seems consistently distracted, bring it up directly. If the problem continues, it's time to find a new therapist who can give you the attention you deserve.

9. Maintains Professional Boundaries

While you may share intimate details with your therapist, the relationship must remain professional. Your therapist is not your friend, and maintaining clear boundaries protects the therapeutic relationship and your treatment outcomes.

Appropriate boundaries include:

No personal relationships outside of therapy
No social media connections (no following/friending on Instagram, Facebook, etc.)
No dual relationships (they shouldn't also be your employee, business partner, etc.)
No romantic or sexual interactions (this is always unethical)
Clear session boundaries (start/end times, payment expectations)

If your therapist invites you to personal events (weddings, parties), asks to meet for coffee as friends, or suggests any kind of personal relationship, these are serious boundary violations. The therapeutic relationship is unique and requires boundaries to be effective.

Red Flags: Signs of Ineffective or Harmful Therapy

While the nine elements above describe good therapy, it's equally important to recognize when therapy isn't working or is actively harmful. Here are warning signs that you need to address concerns or find a new therapist:

Critical red flags (address immediately or leave):

Boundary violations - romantic advances, requests for personal favors, dual relationships
Confidentiality breaches - sharing your information without legal justification
Discrimination - offensive comments about your identity, culture, or beliefs
Pressure tactics - pushing you to do things you're uncomfortable with
Treatment without consent - not explaining or getting agreement for interventions

Warning signs (discuss with therapist or consider switching):

No progress after 3-6 months without explanation or plan changes
Feeling worse consistently after sessions (temporary discomfort is normal, but chronic worsening isn't)
Can't explain their approach or why they're using specific methods
Defensive when questioned or unwilling to discuss concerns
Makes it all about the past without connecting to present concerns
One-size-fits-all approach that doesn't adapt to your specific needs

How to Use This Information

Now that you understand what makes therapy effective, here's how to apply this knowledge to your own therapy experience:

If you're searching for a therapist:

Ask questions during initial consultations about their approach, experience with your concerns, and how they measure progress
Trust your gut after the first session - you should feel heard and hopeful
Don't settle - it's okay to try 2-3 therapists before finding the right fit
Check credentials - ensure they're licensed in your state

If you're currently in therapy:

Evaluate your experience against the nine elements above
Bring up concerns directly with your therapist - good therapists welcome feedback
Give it time - but not too much time; 6-12 sessions should show some progress
Don't stay out of guilt - if it's not working, it's okay to move on

If your current therapy isn't working:

Have an honest conversation - "I'm not seeing the progress I hoped for"
Ask about trying different approaches within your current relationship
Request a referral if your therapist agrees that another specialist might help more
Switch therapists if conversations don't lead to improvements

Remember, wanting a different therapist doesn't mean you've failed or that your current therapist is bad. Sometimes it's simply a matter of fit, approach, or specialization. Mental health counselors have diverse training and specialties, and finding the right match is crucial for your success.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long should I try therapy before deciding if it's working?

Give therapy at least 6-8 sessions before making a final judgment. The first few sessions focus on building rapport and understanding your concerns. However, you should feel heard and hopeful after the first session, and notice some positive changes by session 8-12. If you see absolutely no progress after 12 sessions and your therapist can't explain why or suggest alternative approaches, it may be time to try someone else.

Is it normal to feel worse after therapy sessions?

Yes, temporary discomfort is normal. Therapy often involves discussing painful topics, and you might feel emotionally raw immediately after sessions. However, this discomfort should be temporary (hours, not days) and should decrease over time as you develop coping skills. If you consistently feel worse after sessions for extended periods, discuss this with your therapist. Therapy should ultimately make you feel better equipped to handle life, not consistently worse.

Can I change therapists if I'm not happy?

Absolutely. You can change therapists at any time, for any reason. You don't owe your current therapist an explanation, though many clients find it helpful to have a final session to discuss why they're leaving. If you're uncomfortable with a direct conversation, a brief email thanking them and explaining you're pursuing other options is sufficient. Good therapists understand that fit matters and won't take it personally.

How do I know if I need a different therapist or if I'm avoiding difficult work?

This is a tricky question. Ask yourself: Do I feel respected, heard, and safe with my therapist? Are we working on my goals, or are we working on the goals the therapist set for me? Is there any progress at all, even small changes? If you feel safe and respected but uncomfortable because you're addressing complex issues, that's productive discomfort. If you feel unsafe, disrespected, or judged, or if there's zero progress after several months, those are signs you need a different therapist, not that you're avoiding work.

What should I do if my therapist breaks confidentiality inappropriately?

This is a serious ethical violation. First, document what happened - when, what was shared, and to whom. Then, you can: (1) File a complaint with your state's licensing board, (2) Contact your therapist's supervisor if they work in a clinic or practice group, and (3) Consider reporting to professional organizations like the APA if they're members. You should also find a new therapist immediately, as trust is essential for therapy to work.

Should I be "friends" with my therapist on social media?

No. Professional boundaries include not connecting on social media. Therapists who friend or follow clients on personal social media accounts are violating professional boundaries. Your therapist shouldn't know about your life from your Instagram feed—they should learn about it from you in session. If your therapist has sent you a friend request or accepted yours, this is inappropriate. Consider whether other boundaries might also be unclear in your therapeutic relationship.

How much should therapy cost, and does expensive mean better?

Therapy costs vary widely by location, credentials, and whether you use insurance. In the U.S., expect $100-250 per session without insurance, or a copay of $10-75 with insurance. Price doesn't necessarily indicate quality—some excellent therapists offer sliding scale fees, and some expensive therapists aren't a good fit. Focus on credentials (licensed therapist), approach (evidence-based methods), and fit (do you feel heard?) rather than price alone.

Can online therapy be as effective as in-person therapy?

Yes, research shows that online therapy (video sessions) can be just as effective as in-person therapy for many concerns, including depression, anxiety, and PTSD. The nine elements of good therapy apply equally to online and in-person settings. The key is finding a therapist you connect with who uses evidence-based approaches. Some people prefer online therapy for convenience and accessibility, while others prefer in-person treatment for the physical presence. Choose what works best for your preferences and situation.

What if I can't afford therapy?

Several options exist: (1) Check if you have insurance that covers mental health—many plans do, (2) Look for therapists who offer sliding scale fees based on income, (3) Contact community mental health centers which often provide low-cost services, (4) Check if local universities with counseling programs offer services through their training clinics at reduced rates, (5) Explore online counseling options which may be more affordable, and (6) Contact the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline for immediate support and resource referrals.

When should I consider ending therapy?

Consider ending therapy when: (1) You've achieved your therapeutic goals and feel equipped to handle challenges independently, (2) You've learned effective coping strategies and can apply them without support, (3) Your symptoms have significantly improved or resolved, (4) You and your therapist both agree you're ready. Ending therapy should be a collaborative decision, often with a few final sessions to review progress and create a plan for maintaining improvements. Some people return to therapy later when facing new challenges, which is perfectly normal.

Key Takeaways

Sound therapy is built on nine essential elements, including a non-judgmental environment, clear therapeutic approaches, regular progress reviews, and appropriate professional boundaries.s
You should feel safe, heard, and respected in therapy - if you don't, it's okay to find a different therapist.
Effective therapy shows progress within 8-12 sessions, though meaningful change takes time.e
Your therapist should clearly explain their approach, why they're using it, and how they'll measure your progress.
Red flags like boundary violations, discrimination, or a complete lack of progress after months warrant immediate action.
Changing therapists is normal and acceptable - finding the right fit is crucial for successful treatment.
Both online and in-person therapy can be effective when using evidence-based approaches with a qualified, licensed professional.l

Interested in Becoming a Mental Health Professional?

If you're passionate about helping others through therapy and counseling, explore accredited programs to start your career in mental health.

Explore Therapy Careers